Reese’s Overnight Oats (high protein)

I loved these because of how creamy they turned out. I made them before and I had to write down the exact proportions because of how well they turned out. Now I made these again last night but I ran out of almond milk! So I improvised and used some of the nonfat kefir I had in the fridge. The original written down recipe calls for 2/3 cup almond milk so you can try it either the original way or the way I’ve written it down in the recipe. Both results in creamy delicious oaty goodness. Mmmm.

Reese's Overnight Oats (high protein)

My preference is for multi grain hot cereal rather than Old Fashioned oats simply because they have less calories. But then again they are also tastier, there is more of a complex flavor to them. But both kinds will work here, of course.

Reese's Overnight Oats (high protein)

I was actually surprised how much these overnight oats truly taste like a peanut butter cup. But better! Because it’s healthier, fills you up more, packed with protein, not much sugar, AND it’s creamy (who doesn’t like creaminess?). These proportions are much recommended.

Shared on Fit & Fab Fridays, Healthy 2day

Reese's Overnight Oats (high protein)

Peanut Butter Chocolate “Reeses” Overnight Oats [serves 1]

  • 1/3 cup multi grain hot cereal (or Old Fashioned oats)
  • 1 Tbsp PB2
  • 1/3 scoop chocolate protein powder
  • 8 drops chocolate NuNaturals Stevia
  • scant 1/2 cup unsweetened almond milk
  • *1/4 cup plain nonfat kefir (or another 1/4 cup almond milk)

Mix all of the ingredients together in a bowl. Cover. Stick in the fridge overnight. Ready to eat in the morning, just give em a stir. Delicious and creamy!

Nutritional Facts: 185 calories, 4g sugar, 17g protein

Kammie wants to know:

  • What’s your favorite candy?

  • Do you like your breakfast sweet or savory?

Let me know in the comments below!

Opt In Image
Check Out Undiscovered Kitchen!

Undiscovered Kitchen is an amazing digital farmer's market for small batch, specialty foods with a focus on helping people find foods that fit their lifestyle and health needs. Think small farmers market, but on a very large, national scale!

I have found tons of AWESOME stuff and hard-to-find ingredients on the site. Give them a try.. I guarantee you will fall in love!

xo Kammie


  1. says

    WOW! I’m wild about ‘doctoring’ oatmeal…which I love with anything added to it. I have never ever heard of doing this overnight ‘thing’ and you can be sure I will be enjoying this for br’fast in the morning. Thanks –